Ragtime
Dance Party
With
the Crown Syncopators
Liner
notes
1. Pegasus—A Classic
Rag (copyright 1920 by John Stark) James Scott
Native Missourian James Scott (1885-1938) was working as a
pianist and theater organist for silent films in Kansas City, Kansas,
when John Stark published Scott’s delightfully roguish “Pegasus.” Scott
reportedly
submitted his compositions for publication untitled and was thus
obliged to
accept his publisher’s choice of a title. With this piece, Stark
demonstrated
his penchant for saving money by recycling cover art from earlier
publications:
the “Pegasus,” cover and title, was originally used in 1908 for a march
by
Robert A. Sterling. Nevertheless, Scott’s “Pegasus” has eclipsed Sterling’s piece
to become
a treasured classic in American piano literature.
2. The Cake Walk In
The Sky—Ethiopian Two-Step (copyright 1899 by M. Witmark &
Sons) Ben
Harney
Ben Harney (1872-1938) was one of more colorful
personalities in ragtime history. Billed as the “Originator of
Ragtime,” Harney
electrified audiences on the stage at Tony Pastor’s variety theater in New York City
with his
ragtime piano playing, singing, and dancing. He later toured the
country in a
popular Vaudeville act, even appearing in Europe.
“The Cake Walk In The Sky,” performed here as an instrumental, was
presumably
one of Harney’s stage specialties along with his other coon song hits “You’ve Been a Good Old Wagon, But You’ve
Done Broke Down” and “Mister Johnson, Turn Me Loose.”
3. Hello Frisco
Medley (Introducing: “Hold Me In Your Loving Arms”) From the Ziegfeld Follies of 1915 (copyright 1915
by M. Witmark & Sons) Words by Gene Buck. Music by Louis A. Hirsch
The
Ziegfeld Follies were an annual series of eye-popping
musical revues on Broadway in New
York City that ran for decades starting in 1907.
The hit
song from the 1915 edition of the follies was “Hello, Frisco! (I Called
You Up
to Say “Hello!”),” presented in an elaborate stage production
celebrating the
inauguration of transcontinental telephone service between New York City and San Francisco. Since the invention of
the telephone,
AT&T had wanted to link the phone lines from one side of the
country to the
other. Employing Lee De Forest’s signal-amplifying vacuum tubes placed
along
the 3,400 miles of wires connecting one coast to the other, the first
trial
took place in July 1914, when the president of the company, Theodore
Vail,
spoke from one coast to the other. The big public unveiling of the new
technological feat occurred on 25 January 1915, at a meeting in San Francisco.
Sitting in New York,
Alexander Graham Bell repeated
into the phone what he had once said decades before: “Mr. Watson, come
here. I
want you.” This time, however, Watson, who was sitting in San Francisco,
replied, “It will take me five
days to get there now!”
Included
in our arrangement is another hit song from the
same edition of the Follies, “Hold Me In Your Loving Arms.” Both songs
were
composed by the successful Broadway composers Gene Buck (1885-1957) and
Louis
A. Hirsch (1887-1924). Buck was chief assistant to Florenz Ziegfeld as
well as
a successful sheet music cover artist.
4. Pickles and
Peppers (Copyright 1906 by Adeline Shepherd) Adeline Shepherd
Adaline Shepherd (1883-1950) was born in Algona, Iowa.
She spent most of her life in Milwaukee,
Wisconsin, where she
composed the
enormously successful “Pickles and Peppers” in 1906. In 1908 at the
Democratic
convention in Denver,
“Pickles and Peppers” was played at every appearance of the
presidential
nominee, William Jennings Bryan. She also composed a number of other
rags such
as “Wireless Rag” (1909) and “Live Wires Rag” (1910). In 1910, Shepherd
followed in the footsteps of far too many female ragtime composers and
left the
world of music following her marriage to an insurance executive.
5. Whistling Rufus—A
Characteristic Two Step March (copyright 1899 by F.A. Mills) Kerry
Mills
The cakewalk was a traditional form of music and dance that
originated among slaves in the Southern United
States.
It takes its name from competitions slaveholders sometimes held, in
which they
offered slices of hoecake as prizes for the best dancers. The dance was
inspired by formal European ballroom dances. One common form of
cakewalk dance
involved couples linked at the elbows, lining up in a circle, dancing
forward alternating
a series of short hopping steps with a series of very high kicking
steps.
Costumes worn for the cakewalk often included large, exaggerated bow
ties,
suits, canes, and top hats.
Composer
Frederick Allan “Kerry” Mills ignited the American
cakewalk craze in the 1890s with the publication of “Rastus on Parade”
in 1895.
In 1897, Mills unsuccessfully tried to find a publisher for his next
composition, “At A Georgia Camp Meeting,” and was obliged to form his
own
publishing company just so he could publish it himself. This mistake on
the
part of established publishing houses skyrocketed F.A. Mills to the
forefront
among New York
music publishers. “At A Georgia Camp Meeting” quickly became the best
selling
cakewalk in the history of American music. Mills followed this with a
string of
cakewalk hits including “Whistling Rufus,” which purports to represent
the
musical stylings of an itinerant black musician named “Whistling Rufus”
who
allegedly accompanied cakewalks in the “Black Belt District” of Alabama by
whistling and
strumming on the guitar. The whistling heard in our rendition has been
supplied
by Frederick Hodges.
6. Who Let The Cows
Out?—A Bully Rag (Copyright 1910 by Howard & Browne Music Co.)
Chas.
Humfeld
Loaded with humorous musical quotations, “Who Let The Cows
Out?” was the brainchild of St.
Louis
native and vaudevillian Charles Humfeld. He was nicknamed “Humpy” and
billed as
“The Musical Artist.” At the end of the first strain, the sheet music
calls for
the performer to “make a noise like a cow.” We have honored this
request by the
judicious use of the precision-balanced orchestral cowbell.
7. Honky Tonky—One
Step (Copyright 1916 by Broadway Music Corp.) Chas. McCarron &
Chris
Smith
Charles McCarron (1891-1919) was a well-respected Tin Pan
Alley composer and Vaudeville performer. His published output includes
such
numbers as “Fido Is a Hot Dog Now” (1914), and “Eve Wasn’t Modest ‘till
She Ate
That Apple” (1917). He collaborated chiefly with Albert Von Tilzer, but
fortunately also teamed up with composer Chris Smith (1879-1949) to
write the
fast-paced instrumental “Honky Tonky.”
Smith
was born in Charleston,
South Carolina. While
still a
young lad, he traveled with medicine shows and went into Vaudeville,
where he
performed in acts with Elmer Bowman and Jimmie Durante. He also wrote
music for
Bert Williams. Smith’s most enduring song is the frequently revived
1913 hit “Ballin’
The Jack.”
8. Poor Butterfly.
From the Big Show at the New York Hippodrome. (copyright
1916 by T.B. Harms Co.) Words by John L. Golden. Music by Raymond
Hubbell
The Hippodrome Theatre stood in New York City from 1905 to 1939. It
was
located on Sixth Avenue
between 43rd and 44th streets. The auditorium seated 5,300 people, and
it was
equipped with what was then the state of the art in theatrical
technology. Its
stage was 12 times larger than any Broadway theater and capable of
holding as
many as 1,000 performers at a time, or a full-sized circus. It also had
an
8,000-gallon clear glass water tank that could be raised from below the
stage
by hydraulic pistons for swimming-and-diving shows. The Hippodrome
featured
lavish spectacles complete with circus animals, elephants, diving
horses,
opulent sets, and 500-member choruses. Until the end of World War I,
the
Hippodrome housed all sorts of spectacles then switched to musical
extravaganzas produced by Charles Dillingham, the producer of the
spectacle The Big Show, for which “Poor Butterfly”
was composed. Inspired by Puccini’s opera Madame
Butterfly, the music was written by Raymond Hubbell (1879-1954),
the lyrics
by John Golden (1874-1955). The song was sung in the show by Sophie
Bernard.
Becoming an instant hit and an enduring standard, “Poor Butterfly”
quickly
became the butt of many a musical parody such as Zez Confrey’s “Poor
Buttermilk”
of 1921, the 1917 comedy answer song, “If I Catch the Guy That Wrote
Poor
Butterfly,” and many others.
9. Rabbit’s Foot—Fox
Trot (copyright 1915 by Walter Jacobs) George L. Cobb
George Linus Cobb (1886-1942) was a prolific composer best
known for his first-class ragtime compositions. He was also a prolific
composer
of ragtime songs, collaborating chiefly with Jack Yellen. Their
earliest
success was in 1913 with “All Aboard For Dixie Land,” which was
interpolated
into Rudolf Friml’s Broadway musical production High Jinks,
where Elizabeth Murray’s thrilling interpretation of
the song made it the unqualified hit of the show.
Cobb
scored his biggest instrumental hit with the “Russian
Rag” in 1918 and spent the rest of his musical career as a staff
composer for
the Boston
publishing firm of Walter Jacobs.
10. Pork and
Beans—One Step, Two Step or Turkey
Trot (Copyright 1913 by Jos. W. Stern & Co.) C. Luckyth Roberts
Charles Luckeyeth Roberts, better known as Luckey Roberts
(1887-1968) was born in Philadelphia.
As a young boy, Roberts gained valuable show business experience by
traveling
and performing with Black minstrel shows. He settled in New York City about 1910 and became one of the
most inspiring and
influential pianists in Harlem. Along
with James
P. Johnson and others, Roberts was one of the originators of the
“stride” style
of ragtime piano playing.
Roberts
toured France
and the United Kingdom
with
James Reese Europe during World War I, then returned to New York where
he wrote music for various
shows and recorded piano rolls. Roberts’ compositions include “Junk Man
Rag,” “Moonlight
Cocktail,” and “Railroad Blues.”
An
astute businessman, Roberts became a millionaire twice
through real estate dealings. He also owned restaurants, led dance
orchestras,
and was the featured radio pianist for Moran & Mack, a.k.a The Two
Black
Crows. Luckey’s unique middle name was spelled a variety of ways, two
examples
of which are given above.
11. Queen Rag—Two
Step (copyright 1911 by The Joseph Krolage Music Co.)
Floyd Willis
Floyd Willis was a popular accompanist for silent films in Cincinnati. His
best-known
composition, “Queen Rag,” was named for an Ohio River excursion
steamer, The Island Queen, which ferried
passengers from Cincinnati about ten miles east to a riverside
amusement park
called “Coney Island”—not to be
confused with the better known park of the same name in New York. This
amusement park is still in operation today but the Island Queen
was
destroyed in a fire in 1922, after 26 years of service.
During
its heyday, ragtime was featured on The Island Queen
through the
volume-intensive medium of a steam calliope, the master of which was
Homer
Denny, composer of numerous rags and songs celebrating both Coney Island and the boat on which he worked.
12. Castle House
Rag—Trot and One Step (copyright 1914 by Jos. W. Stern & Co.)
James Reese Europe
James Reese Europe (1881-1919) was a leading figure in the New York music
scene in
the second decade of the 20th century. In about 1912, as
social
dancing became increasingly popular in the United States, the decorated dance team
of Vernon
and Irene Castle hired Europe and his
society
dance orchestra to perform at their “Castle House” dance hall. In this
capacity, Europe composed numerous
pieces that
illustrated the new dances that the Castles innovated and popularized.
Compositions such as “Castle’s Half and Half,” “Castle’s Lame Duck
Waltz,” “The
Castle Maxixe,” “The Castle Innovation Tango,” “The Castle Perfect
Trot,” and
especially the “Castle House Rag,” illustrate Europe’s compositional
flair for
writing snappy dance numbers that perfectly demonstrated the proper
rhythms and
meters of the latest dance sensations.
Europe’s orchestra made a
series of recordings in 1914 for Victor Records. These recordings show
off Europe’s imaginative arranging
style, combining complex
melodies with driving rhythms. When the United
States entered World War I, Europe
signed up and was commissioned a lieutenant. He was ordered to put
together the
best band possible. This regiment became the 369th Regiment, known as
the “Hell
Fighters,” and proceeded to amaze continental Europe
with its brilliant and original American ragtime music.
At
the end of the war, Europe
and his band were welcomed home as heroes and immediately embarked upon
a
nation-wide tour. Europe died
tragically in
1919 when his disgruntled drummer fatally stabbed him in the neck.
There may be
a lesson here for band leaders everywhere.
13. Smoky Mokes—Cake
Walk and Two Step (Copyright 1899 by Feist & Frankenthaler) Abe
Holzmann
Abraham Holzmann (1874-1939) was born in New York City where he studied at the
New
York Conservatory of Music. “Smoky Mokes” was the first of Holzmann’s
many
successful compositions. It is a splendid cakewalk that was also
published as a
song with a “Humorous Darky Text.” He later served as advertising
manager for
the American Federation of Musicians publication, International
Musician. In 1915, “Smoky Mokes” was interpolated
into the Broadway show A Modern Eve
at the Casino Theatre in New
York.
Concerning
the introduction and acceptance of “Smoky Mokes,”
an article that appeared in the New
York Herald on Sunday, 13 January 1901
reported:
When
John Philip Sousa raised his baton to the opening measures of
Composer Holzmann’s famous “Smoky Mokes” last season, the noted
bandmaster’s
audience was nonplussed. Then surprise gave way to delight and
vociferous
applause. Persons in the audience consulting their programmes
discovered a new
genius in their midst. From that hour the name of Holzmann was a byword
for
American cakewalks, and “Smoky Mokes” re-echoed upon the pianos of a
million
music lovers.
14. The Smoky
Topaz—March and Two Step (Copyright 1901 by Daniels & Russell)
Grace M.
Bolen
Grace Marie Bolen (1883-1970) was born into a wealthy Kansas City
family. Her
first composition, “The Fair” (1898), was published when she was just
fifteen
years old. Her most beloved composition, “The Smoky Topaz,” is a
surprisingly
mature work for a young girl of seventeen. Like
Adeline Shepherd, marriage for Bolen spelled the death of her career as
a
composer. Showing true devotion to her new career choice, she actually
got
married twice in 1903. A few years later, she married a third time.
With her
newest husband, newspaper editor Jay Davidson, Bolen moved to Lafayette,
Louisiana, and later to Kilgore, Texas,
where she taught piano and voice. She died in Longview, Texas
where she was known as “Mama Grace.”
15. Wild Cherries Rag
(Copyright 1908 by Ted Snyder Co. Inc.) Ted Snyder
Ted Snyder (1881-1965) was born in Freeport,
Illinois, and gained much practical
musical
experience by performing as a café pianist in Chicago for many
years. In 1908, he formed
his own music publishing company. In 1909, Snyder made the historically
significant move of giving a young Irving Berlin his first job as a
staff
lyricist. Four years later, the two paired up as business partners
along
with Henry Waterson, forming the publishing house of Waterson, Berlin
& Snyder. In fact, upon being hired, one of Berlin’s first assignments was to
write
lyrics for Snyder’s instrumental rag “Wild Cherries.” Berlin came up
with a set of clever coon
song lyrics about a certain Miss Lucinda Morgan White and her rapturous
reaction to the playing of ragtime by Mister Jackson, the leader of a
big brass
band.
16. Pleasant
Moments—Ragtime Waltz (Copyright 1909 by Seminary Music Co.) Scott
Joplin
In addition to their other publishing activities, Ted Snyder
and Henry Waterson owned and operated a small publishing enterprise
called
Seminary Music Company, which they founded in 1906. In 1908, the
enterprising
pair managed to lure Scott Joplin (1869-1917) away from Joseph W. Stern
and
Company and began publishing a series of Joplin’s best and most
sophisticated
compositions, beginning with the” Sugar Cane Rag.” This was soon
followed by “Pine
Apple Rag,” “Wall Street Rag,” “Country Club,” “Euphonic Sounds,”
“Paragon Rag,”
“Solace,” and the ragtime waltz “Pleasant Moments.”
While
most rags are in 2/4 time, ragtime waltzes did exist.
With “Pleasant Moments,” Joplin
effortlessly and gracefully illustrated that any style of music or any
meter
could be ragged.
17. Maori—A Samoan
Dance (Copyright 1913 by Waterson, Berlin & Snyder Co.) Wm. H. Tyers
Although a good number of publications were issued with
William H. Tyers (1876-1924) credited as composer, he spent most of his
musical
career behind the scenes in the music industry working as an arranger
for
various publishing houses. Arranging a song or a piano solo for
publication is
an exacting art that few composers were expected to understand or
master. Such
a financially crucial activity was left to the expertise of the
official
arranger who was trained in the art of creating simplified yet
satisfying
arrangements that would attract rather than intimidate the amateur home
pianist
browsing through the sheet music department of her local music shop.
While most
arrangers never received credit for their work, Tyers was occasionally
credited, most notably on such ragtime gems as the 1899 Joseph W. Stern
edition
of Tom Turpin’s “Harlem Rag” and the 1910 Leo Feist edition of Scott
Joplin’s “Sycamore
Rag.”
Tyers
remained with Stern from 1897 to 1914. Along with
James Reese Europe, Tyers was one of the founders of the Clef Club—a
private
club and booking agency for Black composers and musicians. Throughout
the
second decade of the 20th century, Tyers conducted dance bands and
created band
arrangements for others, including James Europe. Indeed, in 1918, Tyers
traveled to France to act as
arranger and assistant conductor to Europe’s 369th U.S.
Infantry “Hell Fighters” Band.
After returning home in 1919, he
was appointed assistant conductor to Will Marion Cook’s New York
Syncopated
Orchestra. Over the next three years, Tyers toured with this outfit,
even
giving a command performance for King George V of England. During the
summers, Tyers
led the orchestra at the Mount Washington Hotel in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire.
“Maori”
was originally published as a song in 1909 with
lyrics by Henry S. Creamer and is one of a series of Tyer’s pieces
whose titles
evoke exotic locations and peoples. His 1910 tango “Panama” has always been a
favorite
of jazz bands, having been recorded by such groups as the
New Orleans Rhythm Kings, Red Nichols and His
Five Pennies, and Jelly
Roll Morton’s Six. “Maori” has no less a distinguished history,
having
been recorded by Duke Ellington’s Jungle Band in 1930 for Brunswick
Records.
18. Shake It and
Break It (Copyright 1920 by Handy Bros. Music Co. Inc.) Words by H.
Qualli
Clark. Music by Signor “Friscoe” Lou Chiha
The composer of “Shake It and Break It” was a virtuoso
Vaudeville xylophonist with the exotic name of Signor Friscoe, a.k.a.
Lou
Chiha. “Friscoe” made twelve xylophone records for Edison, and while he
was
there, he also participated in the famous tone-tests, in which live
performances were compared with Edison
phonograph recordings in the presence of audiences. An advertisement
for “The
New Edison: The Phonograph with a Soul” (4 September 1920) describes the
spectacle:
Vaudeville’s
Strangest Thrill—Meet Signor Friscoe, xylophone artist
extraordinary—and
vaudeville’s newest purveyor of magic. Meet the New Edison—his chief
“magic.”
Signor Friscoe comes on to the stage and plays. His agile hammers
ripple
merrily over the xylophone keys. Suddenly Signor Friscoe holds his
hammers
poised in mid-air. But his xylophone performance continues—as if some
magic
influence were at work upon the keys. Then the curtains part. The
audience
gasps. The New Edison stands revealed. It has been matching Signor
Friscoe’s
performance so perfectly that its Re-Creation could not be
distinguished from
his original performance.
It
is tempting to imagine that Signor Friscoe was playing “Shake
It and Break It” for this demonstration.
19. The Lion Tamer
Rag—A Syncopated Fantasia (Copyright 1913 by A.F. Marzian) Mark
Janza
Mark Janza was most likely a pseudonym for publisher and
composer Albert Frederick Marzian (1875-1947). Born in Russia to German parents, Marzian
immigrated to
the United States
in about 1887. Marzian was the conductor of the Louisville, Kentucky
Symphony Orchestra and taught high school music. From 1900 onwards, he
lived in
Jefferson County, Kentucky, where he worked as a music
teacher
and theater conductor.
Among
his other notable ragtime compositions are counted “Aviation
Rag” (1910), “Angel Food Rag” (1911), and “Bale O’ Cotton” (1914).
However, “The
Lion Tamer Rag” stands out not only as the best of his compositions but
one of
the best and most exciting rags ever published. Accurately replicating
the
performance style of circus bands, this rag combines acrobatic
pianistic
pyrotechnics with unexpected musical surprises that have no counterpart
in
ragtime literature. Like a circus clown car, trick after trick tumbles
out of
the “The Lion Tamer Rag”—and just when the listener has been lulled
into
thinking that he has seen the last of the musical tricks, out pops
another
series of delightful musical thrills.
Notes
by Frederick Hodges
About the Artists
Formed in 2007, The Crown Syncopators Ragtime Trio
consists of Virginia Tichenor on drums, Marty Eggers on tuba, and
Frederick
Hodges on piano. The trio plays regularly to enthusiastic crowds of
music
lovers at legendary waterfront restaurant Pier
23 in San Francisco
and is expanding its territory
to include ragtime and jazz festivals around the country.
The
trio derives its name from the brand name of the piano
at Pier 23, which happens to be a rare 1909 art-case, four-pedal
upright piano
manufactured by the Crown Piano Company. This very instrument has the
added
distinction of having belonged at different times to Bay Area jazz
piano greats
Burt Bales and Ray Skjelbred. In 2007, Skjelbred sold the piano to
Marty
Eggers, who arranged to house it at Pier 23, where Bales played for
over a
decade in the 1950s and 1960s.
Virginia
Tichenor has been consumed by ragtime her
entire life, as the daughter of Trebor Tichenor, the noted ragtime
scholar,
pianist, collector and founder of the St. Louis Ragtimers. She studied
music at
the St. Louis Community Association for the Arts and took advanced
training
from concert pianist, John Philips. Always at the crossroads of the
ragtime
revival, her parental home houses the world’s largest library of
ragtime sheet
music and piano rolls. Virginia
grew up with legends like Eubie Blake, Max Morath and Butch Thompson
chatting
in her own living room. Her father is advisor-confidant for most of the
ragtime
community, so Virginia
often heard new rags when they were forming in the minds of their
composers.
Since 2001, Virginia has performed
regularly
as the pianist in the Devil Mountain Jazz Band of Oakley, California. Virginia’s
ragtime piano experience has
prepared her well to play the drums, which she has been doing since
2005.
Marty Eggers is a
California
native with deep roots in the ragtime community. In a career spanning
several
decades, Marty has earned a world-wide reputation as a master of
ragtime and
classic jazz piano. Marty has played with numerous Bay Area jazz and
ragtime
groups, including the Black Diamond Jazz Band and Bo Grumpus. Marty is
the
principal bass and tuba player for Don Neely’s Royal Society Jazz
Orchestra. He
also appears at ragtime festivals with the Tichenor Family Trio (Trebor Tichenor, Virginia
Tichenor, and Marty), and performs around the country with the Butch
Thompson Trio
and the Carl Sonny Leyland Trio.
Frederick Hodges
specializes in the piano music and popular songs of the ragtime era,
the 1920s,
and the 1930s. While still in college, he was hired by Don Neely to
serve as
pianist and singer with the famed Royal Society Jazz Orchestra. Soon, Frederick was
playing solo
piano for society parties and holding down steady engagements at
legendary Nob
Hill establishments such as L’Etoile in the Huntington Hotel, Masons in
the
Fairmont Hotel, and the Ritz Carlton Hotel. Frederick also plays piano with the
Peter
Mintun Orchestra, the Jesters vocal trio, and with various jazz
ensembles. In
addition to these musical outlets, Frederick enjoys a career as a
silent film
accompanist, in which capacity he is heard monthly at the Niles Essanay
Silent
Film Museum, the Redding Silent Film Festival, and other silent film
festivals
around the world. As a solo pianist, he is a favorite at jazz and
ragtime
festivals around the country. For more information, please visit Frederick’s
website: www.frederickhodges.com
Production Credits
Recording and mastering engineer: Russell Bond
Second engineer: Justine Milburn
Recording location: The Annex, Menlo
Park, California.
www.musicannex.com
Recording dates: 20 and 21 August 2008
Piano: Yahama Conservatory C-7 Grand Piano
Photographer: Lewis Motisher
Location for photography: Brune-Reutlinger
Mansion, San Francisco, California
Graphics: Sienna Digital, Menlo
Park, California.
www.siennadigital.com
Producers: Virginia Tichenor, Marty Eggers, and Frederick
Hodges
Acknowledgements
First, we would like to thank the following people for their
help and support: Lewis Motisher for his photographic talents, and
Richard
Reutlinger for allowing us to use his beautiful Victorian house as a
backdrop
for our photography session. We also owe a debt of gratitude to our
beloved
fans and musical supporters. Many thanks to each and every one of you.
For bookings and
information, e-mail marty_eggers@juno.com or call (510) 655-6728.
This recording and
the musical arrangements contained in it copyright © 2008 by
Tichenor, Eggers & Hodges.
Liner
notes copyright 2008 by Frederick Hodges